website of the committee for a workers' international, CWI
Union leaders discuss sell out despite historic action
Michael O’Brien, Socialist Party (CWI Ireland)
250,000 public service workers in southern Ireland took part in the one day strike on 24 November in opposition to the threatened cut of €1.3 billion from the public service pay bill in next month’s budget, on top of similar sized cuts in Social Welfare payments and in public service provision itself. €2.5 billion was already taken from these workers in a mis-named ‘pension levy’, which on top of other new taxes on income, saw low and middle earners in the public service lose thousands of euro from their pay packets.
The government and media wanted the 24 hour public service strike to be marked by incidents of a hostile general public venting abuse at a so-called ‘cosseted and privileged’ section of the workforce. Indeed, many of the workers who Socialist Party members spoke to on pickets around the country confided that they were nervous of such a response; such has been the campaign of vilification in the pro-capitalist press.
Instead, incidents of hostility were more the exception than the rule and were far outweighed by signs of support from passers-by, who honked their car horns in appreciation for the work of public servants. For many, it was their first ever strike action, and across the board rank and file members stepped forward to look after the logistics of getting placards and working out picketing rotas.
So, the best the media could come up with on the day to denigrate the striking workers was to concoct a story that shopping malls in cross-border towns, like Newry, in N Ireland, were flooded with public sector workers, who instead of attending to the picket lines, decided to go Christmas shopping!
The Socialist Party’s call for a follow up 48-hour strike, in advance of the budget, coupled with a campaign to get private sector workers on board for future actions, was listened to by workers, who are reconciled to further action being needed to force the Fianna Fail/Green government to back down. Currently, 3 December 2009, remains the date set by the unions for the next day of strike action, apart from IFUT (university lecturers) and the AHCPS (senior civil servants) who need to ballot again for any further action.
Socialist Party MEP visits picket line
Before flying back to Dublin to support the strike, Joe Higgins, Socialist Party MEP (CWI in Ireland) spoke in the European parliament in support of the strike. Click here to watch the video
Socialist Party MEP, Joe Higgins, flew back from a plenary session of the European Parliament, in Strasbourg, to visit picket lines at James Connolly Hospital, Dublin, and at Fingal County Council, in Blanchardstown, before touring the city centre picket lines at various government departments, museums and galleries. The contrast with establishment politicians from government and so-called ‘opposition’ who gave the pickets a wide berth was not lost on picketers who were pleased with Joe’s support.
While the government were surely rattled by the turnout and the generally positive response of the public, they will take some encouragement from the line argued the next day by Peter McLoone, General Secretary of IMPACT (public sector union) and Chair of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions (ICTU) public services committee, who has publicly conceded that there will be cuts in public service expenditure, which he argues should be ‘temporary’.
Peter McLoone and the other trade union leaders are back in talks with the government. They are attempting to make a deal that will supposedly leave “core pay rates” intact, but which, in reality, will mean major pay cuts for public sector workers. Discussions are taking place around the idea of reducing the pay bill by cutting paid holidays, extending the working week, extending the working day from 8.00am to 8.00pm, paying overtime at basic rates and imposing 12 days unpaid leave. No matter how they try to package such a deal, it basically will result in pay cuts for all public sector workers. This is a disastrous position which, if came into effect, would severely cut the pay of nurses, paramedics, fire fighters, prison officers and others who work anti-social hours, as well as low paid administrative workers who have depended on overtime to supplement their meagre basic pay.
The lack of leadership and a real fight by the trade union leaders during this crisis has fed a certain cynicism among many workers who see an inevitability to cuts in pay but feel that a stand must still be made. This outlook is not borne of support for the idea that cuts need to be made but rather the lack of any alternative and the constant propaganda from the establishment parties, the media and also trade union leaders that everyone must share in the pain!
The ICTU leaders are prepared to make a rotten deal with the government that will cut the pay of public sector workers, weaken working conditions and potential lead to up to 20,000 job losses. The depth of the crisis is such that it may not be possible for the government and the union leaders to concoct a deal that is “sellable” to union members. Regardless of the choreography at the top between government, employers and union leaders, an active response is needed from the ranks of the unions to reject any sell-out deal.
The Socialist Party believes the next stage in this struggle should be a 48-hour public sector strike. At the same time, the unions should broaden out the campaign to include fighting pay cuts and redundancies in the private sector. On that basis, the unions should call combined action of public and private sector workers - a one day general strike to defeat the government and push back the employers
Committee for a Workers' International
PO Box 3688, London E11 1YE, Britain, Tel: ++ 44 20 8988 8760, Fax: ++ 44 20 8988 8793, email@example.com