Sign the petition to defend Deputy Vanessa “Vedi” Emde!
Die Linke (Left Party) emerged as the strongest party in September’s Berlin House of Representatives elections and is currently negotiating forming a coalition with the Social Democrats and the Greens.
Even before the elections, Die Linke faced fierce attacks due to its relatively radical election platform, which includes, among other things, the expropriation of large real estate corporations. Following the party’s electoral success, these attacks have escalated—most notably through the use of baseless accusations of antisemitism.
This led to the signing, before the actual coalition negotiations began, of a joint “preliminary exploratory statement” by the three would-be coalition partners on the issue of “antisemitism”. However, despite Left Party leaders agreeing to it this statement it actually stands in sharp contradiction to policy resolutions of the Left Party. With their signature these leading Left Party negotiators basically accepted that their party had an “antisemitism problem”.
The attacks on Die Linke have focused—and continue to focus—on the party’s Neukölln district organisation in Berlin and in particular its local candidate, Vanessa “Vedi” Emde, who was elected as a directly elected constituency member of the House of Representatives with 46.2 percent of the vote in her constituency.
Already, prior to the formation of the parliamentary group of House members, all elected Die Linke representatives—including Emde—signed another document which said the parliamentarians would respect party decisions. A declaration of that notion had to be signed by all Linke candidates before the elections anyway.
Now however, this new document explicitly mentioned specific resolutions which need to be supported, but only those that backed the “right of Israel to exist.” Other national and regional party resolutions which for example support the Jerusalem Declaration of Antisemitism, the legitimacy of a rejection of Zionism and a debate about the question of ‘what state forms a democratic solution in Israel/Palestine could take’, are not mentioned.
“Israel’s right to exist” is a formula that has been used for years by the ruling establishment in Germany as part of defending their political, financial and military support for various Israeli governments and their oppressive and militaristic policies. No such recognition of a “right to exist” is demanded for any other state—not even for Germany itself. The “right to exist” of a state, in its specific political and constitutional form, is something distinct from the right of nations to self-determination, as advocated by Marxists.
As Sol (CWI Germany) wrote at the time:
“The term “right to exist” is understood in different ways. Socialists advocate for the abolition of all capitalist states and for the creation of democratic socialist states in their place. They do not treat this issue as a legal matter, but as a question of political struggle over power and property relations. The State of Israel is a capitalist, reactionary, imperialist, and racist entity. It has a religiously influenced constitution and institutionalizes discrimination against Palestinians. The left in Israel aims to fundamentally transform this state or replace it with another. However, “Israel’s right to exist” is generally not understood as political support for the State of Israel in its current form and political character, but rather as the right of Jewish people to their own state. Marxists should support this right to self-determination of the Israeli nation, which has developed since the state’s founding in 1948. To deny this right by pointing out that the Israeli state defines itself as a “Jewish state” or was established as a “colonial settler state” is to deny a reality that has evolved over more than 65 years.
“Sol advocates for a socialist solution to the so-called “Middle East conflict” in which the national and democratic rights of all ethnic and religious groups are safeguarded. We believe that, under current conditions, this goal is most likely to take the form of an independent socialist Palestine alongside a socialist Israel, with two capitals in Jerusalem and full rights for minorities. It is clear, however, that the organizations of workers and oppressed peoples will democratically negotiate and decide on state borders and forms once they have overthrown today’s rulers and have the opportunity to do so. However, this conviction does not prevent us from advocating for an open debate on a peaceful and socially just future in the Middle East, including legitimate demands for a democratic or socialist one-state solution with equal rights for all citizens”.
Vanessa “Vedi” Emde signed the new document as well and, on that basis, became a member of the parliamentary group.
Afterwards she stated on social media that, in line with international law and party resolutions, she maintains the view that it is human beings, not states, who possess a right to exist and its legitimate to raise the demand for a democratic one-state-solution with equal rights.
This led to intense attacks from other political parties and the media. The Linke leadership unfortunately failed to consistently defend Emde and other members against baseless accusations of antisemitism.
Under the media and political pressure, the party’s regional executive then demanded Emde resign her mandate – though they argued this was due to her failures to “cooperate” with the party and parliamentary group. Emde rightly rejected.
Now the parliamentary group’s leadership demands from the parliamentary group to expel her. Rather than accusing Emde of antisemitism, they argue, they have no “trusting working relationship” anymore. This shifts the issue from the political realm to the sphere of personal conduct—an area where it is far more difficult for party members to form an informed opinion, and where the rumour mill is given free rein. Criticism of any representative’s conduct can and should be discussed with the right for the ‘accused’ to defend themselves. However, those criticisms made of Emde in this regard would not justify an expulsion.
The real reason for the intended expulsion is obviously another: it is the demand made by Die Linke’s potential coalition partners. A two-thirds majority within the parliamentary group is required for her expulsion. Supporters of Vedi Emde have now launched a petition urging the representatives not to vote in favour of the expulsion. The petition is not directed solely at members of Die Linke; the organisers explicitly state: “Our goal is to collect as many signatures as possible from across Germany and beyond.” This is clearly an invitation for socialists outside of Germany to participate.
Within Die Linke, there is considerable outrage regarding this scandalous course of action—even among party members who do not oppose coalitions with pro-capitalist parties in principle. For members of Sol (CWI in Germany), this conflict serves as an opportunity to explain that the ruling class and its parties will not permit Die Linke to implement fundamental improvements in the interest of the working class when it forms governments with pro-capitalist parties.
Instead, they employ blackmail, intimidation, and slander—either preventing the formation of a coalition altogether or breaking the left wing of Die Linke to such an extent that (the party) becomes willing to govern in a way that contradicts its own campaign promises and the interests of its voters. Even the exploratory talks held prior to the commencement of formal coalition negotiations have already led Die Linke to dilute key campaign promises—or, in some cases, to invert them entirely. The demand for the expropriation of real estate corporations, for instance, has been significantly watered down and loopholes for the coalition partners have been inserted to derail the project down the road. Cuts, e.g. in social services, have been de facto accepted. On the other side, the agreement supports strengthening the police—a force notorious for racism against migrants and one that, in recent years, has regularly used brutality against pro-Palestinian protesters. Supporters of Vedi Emde point out that Die Linke did not receive a strong share of the vote solely because of its demand to expropriate real estate corporations; rather, it also garnered significant support—particularly among voters with a migrant background— due to its anti-racist stance and its solidarity with Palestinians which the leadership in now ready to abandon.
For these reasons we appeal to readers both in Germany and internationally to sign the petition fast since the parliamentary group intends to vote on the expulsion sometime on Tuesday 21 November 2026.
You can sign the petition here: https://keine-fraktion-ohne-vedi.de/
English translation of the text of the petition:
Solidarity with Vanessa “Vedi” Emde – No to expulsion!
For a strong Left that unites struggles and takes a stand.
Dear comrades and members of the Left Party faction in the Berlin House of Representatives,
We—comrades and supporters of the Left Party, Berliners, voters, high school students, college students, union members, and supporters of the Palestine solidarity movement in Germany and internationally—are shocked by the motion to expel Vanessa “Vedi” Emde.
It is a democratic scandal that leading representatives of the SPD and the Greens are making her expulsion a condition for a governing coalition with The Left in Berlin, thereby treating an elected representative as a bargaining chip. The fact that the Left Party’s state executive committee and now also the parliamentary group executive committee of The Left in Berlin are bowing to this pressure and the media smear campaign, instead of standing up to protect their own representative, is a political failure. It damages the credibility of The Left far beyond Berlin.
Vedi was directly elected in her district and received 46.2 percent of the first-choice votes—the third-best result in all of Berlin. We reject the baseless defamations and insinuations against her. We oppose a “reason of state” that defames criticism of Israel as anti-Semitism. It is not Israel’s existence that is under acute threat, but the lives of Palestinians and the existence of Palestine.
We stand in solidarity with Vanessa “Vedi” Emde and demand that she remain in the Left Party parliamentary group. Vedi stands for a politics that unites people and social struggles—standing alongside striking colleagues, student protests against mandatory military service and for quality education, and the solidarity movement for Palestine. This isn’t just about Vedi: An attack on one of us is an attack on all of us. We need representatives with backbone who listen sincerely and have the courage to speak the truth—in parliament and on the streets.
- We call on all representatives of The Left to vote against the motion to expel Vanessa “Vedi” Emde and to vote for her to remain in The Left parliamentary group.
- We call on the Left Party parliamentary group in Berlin to actively oppose the criminalisation of the Palestine solidarity movement and racist police violence, and to stand up for the protection of freedom of expression, assembly, and artistic freedom in Berlin.
- No parliamentary group without solidarity with Palestine, no parliamentary group without Vedi!
